Card Garage Pokémon TCG market prices Track your collection →

How we calculate prices

Every card shows a TCGplayer market price and, where available, an eBay sold price. The TCGplayer number comes straight from their nightly catalog feed. The sold price is more involved — we don't have a single reliable sold-comps feed, so we fall back through a chain of sources, trying the most trustworthy one first.

The source chain

  1. Observed sales. We continuously track eBay's active listings for each card. When a single-quantity listing disappears, or a listing's quantity drops, that's evidence of a sale. Enough of these events accumulate into a real, first-party sold-price history — no third party involved. This is the most trustworthy source, especially once a card has several confirmed quantity-drop sales (as opposed to a listing simply vanishing, which is a weaker signal).
  2. Third-party aggregate. When we don't yet have enough observed sales for a card, we fall back to a third-party sold-price data provider. It's a solid source, but it's one step removed from the actual sale, so we rank it below our own observed data.
  3. Asking-price estimate. As a last resort, we estimate a sold price from the median of current active ("Buy It Now") listings. This is the weakest source — an asking price isn't a sale — so it's only used when nothing better is available, and only when there are enough listings to make a reasonable median.

Sanity-checked against TCGplayer

Before any sold price is stored, we compare it against the card's TCGplayer market price for the same finish (Normal, Holo, Reverse Holo). A sold value has to fall within a plausible range of that price — roughly a quarter to four times it — or it's rejected outright rather than stored. This catches the most common failure modes: a mismatched listing (wrong card, wrong set), a graded copy mixed into an ungraded average, or bad data from an upstream source. A rejected value never overwrites a good one — we simply keep showing the last known-good price.

Every price also carries a confidence tier — high, medium, or low — built from its source, its sample size, and how recently it was refreshed. A thin sample or a stale value is marked down a tier even if the source itself is a strong one. Click the confidence meter next to any sold price to see exactly which of these factors applied.

What this means for you

A sold price is never just a number — it's a source, a sample size, a freshness check, and a plausibility check, all visible on demand. We'd rather show you a lower-confidence estimate with an honest label than hide a card's price entirely.